Powder Measure Accuracy & Does Powder Charge Affect Accuracy.

  • 561 Views
  • Last Post 2 weeks ago
Wm Cook posted this 3 weeks ago

“ Looks like a portion of this post drifted off into powder measure reviews. Maybe that subject is a topic all by itself?

Tom”

Per Tom’s suggestion I’ve started a thread specific to powder measures.

Do you trust your powder measure and at what point would the inaccuracy of the powder charge device affect accuracy? Thanks, Bill Cook.

Attached Files

Order By: Standard | Newest | Votes
Tom Acheson posted this 3 weeks ago

Be careful on two counts regarding electronic scales:

Their “tare setting” can drift.

The unit of measure selector can get “bumped” and you can be looking @ grams and not grains. I made that mis-step just once. Fortunately the gun’s action was strong!

Powder measure setting? The micrometer adjuster on my Reddings is quite repeatable. Find a setting, throw (10) consecutive charges and divide that accumulated weight by 10. Does it align with your desired single charge weight?

Some powder granule shapes and sizes can vary and impact your desired single charge weight.

Tom

Attached Files

Lucky1 posted this 3 weeks ago

Digital scales are great for weighing bullets or cases; but the wandering tare has meant I only trust my old fashioned balance beam Redding for charges. I agree that I can't trust any of the three digitals I have used.

Scott Ingle

Attached Files

  • Liked by
  • Glenn R. Latham
RicinYakima posted this 3 weeks ago

As a reloading tool collector, I have been through many powder measures. The Redding and RCBS measures with micrometer stems are just fine for me. Ohaus was another good one, but at the present time I am running three Harrell's Brothers measures. Small and larger chambers and they are very accurate, as in 0.01's of a grain with fine powders. Technique is just as important as the tool.

For an electronic scale, I am using a GemPro 250, sadly now out of business. When I was on the drug lab raid team, the biggest and high class drug dealers all used GemPro scales. Never an issue with wondering tare as I leave it pluged into 110V outlet 24/7. On battery power, you might as well use a measureing spoon. 

Having only shot cast bullet bench rest matches, I can't see that a 2% difference ever made an impact difference for me. 

Attached Files

Wm Cook posted this 3 weeks ago

“….. at what point would the inaccuracy of the powder charge device affect accuracy?”

For 100, 200 yard BR, would +/- .2 grain be seen in the group size? Bill.

Attached Files

  • Liked by
  • RicinYakima
John Carlson posted this 3 weeks ago

I do use the RCBS digital for powder but not for dribbling, only for dumping a charge into the pan.  Scale gets zeroed for each weighing.  I also use the RCBS Uniflow Micrometer powder measure backed up by the scale.  Repeatability of the measure varies a lot by powder types.  Fine granulars like 2400 seldom vary by .1gn.  Large tubular powders can vary as much as .5gn.  I never rely on the micrometer setting alone since I find it doesn't repeat reliably enough to satisfy my OCD.  I do know some who use powder measures exclusively, no scales.

John Carlson. CBA Director of Military Competition.

Attached Files

  • Liked by
  • RicinYakima
Tom Acheson posted this 3 weeks ago

I’m on my 4th digital scale.

I use small charge weights in large capacity cases. For weighing each charge, I use a Redding set a couple of grains light and trickle up to the desired weight using a RCBS “trickler”. Then after a block of (50) are done, use a small dowel as a dipstick to check for any empty or double charged cases.

Overly cautious but…..

Tom

Attached Files

Eutectic posted this 3 weeks ago

I have two RCBS measures and three drums. The small drum does almost all rifle loading including match loads. The modified "extra small" drum throws a max of 20 grains of 2400 and does all the pistol loading including match loads.

I check measure settings on a RCBS electronic scale. I have a set of standard weights and use one in range of the charge to check accuracy EVERY DAY. You must check any digital scale, they can lie! The calibration weights are NOT sufficient. 

Over the years I have used measures by Lachmiller, Lyman, LEE, and Redding. I seldom miss them. 

Steve

Attached Files

  • Liked by
  • RicinYakima
delmarskid posted this 3 weeks ago

I use my Lyman 55 and an old Ohaus electronic from Midway. I need to check it against my beam scale.

Attached Files

Wilderness posted this 3 weeks ago

I'm a pretender here, since I don't do the serious accuracy stuff, but for my competitions and field use I measure from a Redding to a Lyman (Ohaus) balance, then to the case. I don't think I'm wasting all that much time doing it this way, since all but a few charges usually are good.

From a safety standpoint I prefer doing it this way. If using just the balance, it can't be all that difficult to set a balance with the poise 5 gns off where it is meant to be, especially with old eyes. Going from a preset measure to the balance acts as a check on the setting of the balance.

Even with ball powders, 748 and LVR, the occasional measured charge will come along .2 or .3 gns off - I dump the heavies and adjust the lights. These variations are probably not important.

Flake powders such as Unique and Red Dot, both of which I use or have used in reduced loads for .30-30, are another matter altogether. In loading 50 cartridges I will quite often encounter one or two really light charges, say 3 gns when the intent is 5 for instance. This appears to be from bridging as the chamber fills. I have not encountered bridging in the drop tube. Going from measure via the balance to to the case saves me from the squibs.

My flirtation with electronic balances was brief.

You are only as good as your library.

Attached Files

  • Liked by
  • Glenn R. Latham
RicinYakima posted this 3 weeks ago

Not with the Military rifles I shot for 20 years. 

Attached Files

Shopdog posted this 3 weeks ago

Lyman Accumeasure's are incredibly accurate for handgun loads. Even with known troublemakers like 700X. The RCBS uniflows depend on the powders. Long kernel powders can and do bridge,irrespective of rotor bore size. I weigh all rifle charges on a Lyman beam scale. It is tuned to a kernel or two of 4350. I'm not in a hurry,and actually like handloading.

Attached Files

fa38 posted this 3 weeks ago

When setting my powder measures (2 Reddings and a Harrell) I always approach the measure setting for a particular charge weight from one direction, low to high on the measure scale.  If want 25.9 I go from say 25.5 to 25.9 and the next time I go from 30.8 down to 25.9 I don’t get the, same charge weight.  It may be my technique, but I think it is the slop in the powder chamber setting screw.

When filling the measure powder chamber, I will bump the measure against the fill stop with a small movement a few times.  This really helps with flake powders to get a consistent weight.

Marty

Attached Files

Wm Cook posted this 3 weeks ago

“….. at what point would the inaccuracy of the powder charge device affect accuracy?”

For 100, 200 yard BR, would +/- .2 grain be seen in the group size? Bill.

 

 

 

Attached Files

Tom Acheson posted this 3 weeks ago

Interesting that the black powder crowd, in some situations, just fill the case and scrape off the “excess” powder to be flush with the case mouth.

Black powder is an explosion while smokeless is a progressive detonation. Those performance differences cause us to approach both powder types differently.

I too am interested in the detectible accuracy difference @ 200-yards of the small charge weight variable of powder. That will include multiple test loads, trying to offset environmental influences and solid bench technique's.

It won’t be me. We only do 200-yard matches each year, too few to derive any conclusions.

Tom

Attached Files

fa38 posted this 3 weeks ago

I think it made a difference in my Ballard 25-20 at 200 yards at my last ASSRA match at Beeson's range near Erna Green.  Not home for at least another week so can't report the load I used. Will make a test my loads when I get home.

 

 

Attached Files

Oldman 1950 posted this 3 weeks ago

I shoot 5 different rifles in 32-40 Win. All of them like different bullets and powder charges. IMR 4227 is my go-to powder in them and accuracy is affected by more than 0.1 grain plus or minus. The only powder measure that I use these days is a Belding & Mull. I set the measure tube with a Dillon Digital scale and usually charge 80 cases at a time. Out of the 80 charges none of them are off by more than 0.1 Grain. I also use the Belding & Mull with H4895 for a different rifle and the weights are within 0.2 grains. It seems like I can still keep accuracy with H4895 powder being off by 0.3 or 0.4 grains.

 

A. J. Palik

Any day you wake-up sucking air will be a good day

Attached Files

  • Liked by
  • muley
beagle6 posted this 3 weeks ago

After 65 years of handloading I think I've collected every gadget and gizmo possible.  One thing I've found very useful and very affordable is the Lee powder measure set, a collection of plastic scoops and a slide rule type of thing that shows what each scoop will throw with a specific powder.. Very handy and what could possibly go wrong with a plastic scoop? I hardly ever weigh powder anymore.

Attached Files

  • Liked by
  • Ken Campbell Iowa
  • muley
Eutectic posted this 2 weeks ago

YES, the LEE scoops get used! Usually not to measure powder into a case,but as a quick check on the measure. Pick a scoop slightly large see where the charge fills. Dump it into the scale as a double check the first time. The scoop is used every 100 rounds.

A quick check for bridging is to fill the scoop 50 times. You can see a 5% difference. 

I always double tap on both fill and delivery. This is not important with ball powders. Somewhat with extruded. Very important with flake powders.    

Attached Files

Close