Expander flaring question

  • 459 Views
  • Last Post 02 February 2024
  • Topic Is Solved
max503 posted this 31 January 2024

 This is about reloading lead and powder coated rounds for my Rossi 357 rifle.  I use an old set of RCBS steel dies.  The expander ball measures .3555".  Not having pin gauges, the nearest I can tell, that die produces cases with an I.D. of .355".  

Normally, for lead loads out of a 357, you would size to .358".  Well, my Rossi shoots best with boolits sized to .3565".  That's what my tightest sizer die produces.  

I'd like to experiment with cases with a larger I.D.  My questions are: Can I purchase a larger expander for this die?  My other question is, if I got on a lathe and made an expander, what size threaded rod/bolt would I make it out of?  The threads on the expander measure .558".  I couldn't match that up to an existing thread size.  

Hope that makes sense.  Here's a pic of the expander:

Attached Files

Order By: Standard | Newest | Votes
MP1886 posted this 02 February 2024

By the way an update, then I'm done and won't bother you all in this thread.  I just ordered a Lyman M die. I couldn't get it for the cartridge I wanted. I wanted something with a long neck.  I purchased one in 30-40 Krag. After I receiver it I will do an very thorough examination and test with it to clear up my accusations and put them rest. 

Attached Files

MP1886 posted this 02 February 2024

Generally speaking dual purpose seat/crimp dies are roll or taper based on correct for cartridge. As far as bringing up jacketed rifle bullets in a discussion about expanding for a .357 makes no sense. Pistol expanders for straight will cartridges mainly bell mouth the case. Lyman M die used for bottle necked cartridges is a different thing all together. But you know this, right?

 

The OP wants an expander that does both bells and expands for less case mouth tension. It seems that the answer to his inquiry has been answered. In reloading and bullet casting one size does not fit all. One method is not always superior. Two or more folks can be right at the same time with different ways of getting there.

 

Mark you are correct in what you posted. I only brought the M die mentioning jacketed bullets because Lyman modified the their jacketed M die to be more suitable to cast bullets by making the tighter expanded portion a little larger for cast bullet use, and then putting a bell flare on it if you turn the expander down deeper. They should have tapered the ledge/step too. Now my real opinion is they should have just brought out an RCBS type as they aren't patented. 

Attached Files

MarkinEllensburg posted this 02 February 2024

Generally speaking dual purpose seat/crimp dies are roll or taper based on correct for cartridge. As far as bringing up jacketed rifle bullets in a discussion about expanding for a .357 makes no sense. Pistol expanders for straight will cartridges mainly bell mouth the case. Lyman M die used for bottle necked cartridges is a different thing all together. But you know this, right?

 

The OP wants an expander that does both bells and expands for less case mouth tension. It seems that the answer to his inquiry has been answered. In reloading and bullet casting one size does not fit all. One method is not always superior. Two or more folks can be right at the same time with different ways of getting there.

Attached Files

MP1886 posted this 02 February 2024

MP 1886

You really are back to your old ways again.........

Your assumption on why I honed the step of the Lyman M-die expander is incorrect as are most of your assumptions regarding me.  

I have no idea why you are bringing your usual analogies [the 30-30 question] into this thread.  It makes no sense.  How do you know, how have you measured whether or not there is equal tightness on the bullet?  You don't know, it's just your usual BS unless YOU apply an incorrect roll crimp and it buckles.  I don't and I've roll crimped a lot of jacketed bullets in the 30-30 cartridge because I learned long ago to crimp in a separate step.  However, it is a moot point because I've used a Lee Factory Crimp die for years.  Again, what does this 30-30 crimping have to do with the thread topic about an RCBS expander.....absolutely nothing.   

I suggest you get a life instead of trying desperately to prove me wrong on everything.

LMG

 

Settle down now larry.  If you read it right I was asking.  Answer this for me, if you size that 30-30 case and expand the neck with a M die and you run it into the seater dies, does the case neck have any resistance at all when the neck of the case enters the neck portion of the die?

My other question is just why do you hone the ledge/step out of the M die? Must be a reason since you and everyone think they are perfect dies. 

 

Please keep your insults to yourself. 

Attached Files

Larry Gibson posted this 02 February 2024

MP 1886

You really are back to your old ways again.........

Your assumption on why I honed the step of the Lyman M-die expander is incorrect as are most of your assumptions regarding me.  

I have no idea why you are bringing your usual analogies [the 30-30 question] into this thread.  It makes no sense.  How do you know, how have you measured whether or not there is equal tightness on the bullet?  You don't know, it's just your usual BS unless YOU apply an incorrect roll crimp and it buckles.  I don't and I've roll crimped a lot of jacketed bullets in the 30-30 cartridge because I learned long ago to crimp in a separate step.  However, it is a moot point because I've used a Lee Factory Crimp die for years.  Again, what does this 30-30 crimping have to do with the thread topic about an RCBS expander.....absolutely nothing.   

I suggest you get a life instead of trying desperately to prove me wrong on everything.

LMG

Concealment is not cover.........

Attached Files

MP1886 posted this 02 February 2024

Notice even LARRY GIBSON MENTIONED HE HONED THE STEP OR LEGDE out of the Lyman M die. That should tell you something I've been harpening on.  You say you have no problems with them. Does that just mean you load them and they go bang and hit the target?  You need to load some plainbase softer alloy bullets using the M die and pull a pull on a dummy cases you seated one in and see what he has done to the that flat base and the diameter of the bullet compared to what diameter it was loaded. Larry didn't eliminate that ledge/step for no good reason. 

So are you all going to tell me that if you're loading a jacketed bullet such as say a 170 grain 30-30 bullet with a canelure and you roll crimp the case mouth into the cannelure groove and the ENTIRE case neck that contacts such bullet is equal tightness on the bullet? Remember a roll crimp, which is incorporated in many seating dies only rolls the mouth edge into the cannelure groove if you are using it.  Seating dies are not taper crimp dies that would definitely insure the entire case neck touching the bullet is tight against the bullet. 

Attached Files

Larry Gibson posted this 02 February 2024

I use Lyman M dies, the Lee case expander, NOE expanders and the RCBS expanders plus those that may have come with other makes of dies.  Like MarkinEllensburg, I have no problems with the Lyman M dies.  I use them as is with many different cartridges and have even honed the step off a couple to make it a bevel instead of a step.  I also use the M die when loading 25-20s and, particularly, the ver thin necked 22Hornet cases with jacketed bullets.  Adjusting the M die so the jacketed bullet base just sits inside the neck has eliminated scrunched necks with those cases.  The NOE expanders work as well.  The Lee, which just flairs the case mouth also has its applications but case length is critical with it as it is with the RCBS Universal.

Thus, since I use them all where their application is best I don't recommend any over the others.

LMG

Concealment is not cover.........

Attached Files

  • Liked by
  • Glenn R. Latham
Bud Hyett posted this 02 February 2024

I've used the RCBS expander dies with good results for years. They are cumbersome to change and then adjust.

I'm switching to the K&M expander system as I add new calibers. This system is easier to change mandrels and easier to make custom mandrels. The adjustment is moving the body up and down in the press.

K+M Expander Website.

 

Farm boy from Illinois, living in the magical Pacific Northwest

Attached Files

MarkinEllensburg posted this 02 February 2024

I've been preaching the snow job the Lyman M type dies have been doing for years.  Glad some are starting to see the light. Each reloading tool companies have some really good items along with a lot of bad ones. 

I've not had issues with the Lyman M dies that I have used. It depends on the application. Just like it is easy to say that every forum has members that are self appointed experts, and few actual experts. I allow that there are often more ways to accomplish a task than just one. 

Not everyone has the capabilities to make or use a custom made expander stem. My most used expander is a custom for 30 caliber but my 25 caliber Lyman works just fine. My new Hornady for 450 Bushmaster leaves lots to be desired with only the die body to adjust because the stem is fixed. Guessing they do that to sell more die sets, although it seems RCBS has a better system. 

Attached Files

MP1886 posted this 02 February 2024

I'm in the RCBS expander camp, not liking the step that the M die provides. I feel that step is detrimental to the perfectly achieved sharp square base of a soft plain base bullet, maybe not so much if a gas check is involved, and maybe the issue is all in my head but I'll err on the conservative side. Another advantage of the RCBS, for me, is it's easier to make custom expanders in my lathe for it. (And yes I typically just use cold rolled steel for them as it would take thousands of cycles before they start showing wear, and if is for a high volume application I simply case harden it with Kasenit.)

Two recent homebuilt expanders projects: one for .32 S&W Long/H&R Magnum when loading .314 bullets. The expander in my RCBS die set is obviously intended for .312 jacketed stuff (.308" diameter expander plug), so I use my RCBS expander die with my custom .312 diameter plug in lieu of that die. Problem solved, and I have a simple trumpet flair on the case mouths that is easily removed via the roll crimp. Ditto the same situation with a recently built .40-65 Ballard - the same exact situation as with the .32 dies wherein the die set's expander was a gross mismatch for my bullet diameter. (Pretty soft plain based bullets employed in both.)

 

I've been preaching the snow job the Lyman M type dies have been doing for years.  Glad some are starting to see the light. Each reloading tool companies have some really good items along with a lot of bad ones. 

Attached Files

gnoahhh posted this 02 February 2024

I'm in the RCBS expander camp, not liking the step that the M die provides. I feel that step is detrimental to the perfectly achieved sharp square base of a soft plain base bullet, maybe not so much if a gas check is involved, and maybe the issue is all in my head but I'll err on the conservative side. Another advantage of the RCBS, for me, is it's easier to make custom expanders in my lathe for it. (And yes I typically just use cold rolled steel for them as it would take thousands of cycles before they start showing wear, and if is for a high volume application I simply case harden it with Kasenit.)

Two recent homebuilt expanders projects: one for .32 S&W Long/H&R Magnum when loading .314 bullets. The expander in my RCBS die set is obviously intended for .312 jacketed stuff (.308" diameter expander plug), so I use my RCBS expander die with my custom .312 diameter plug in lieu of that die. Problem solved, and I have a simple trumpet flair on the case mouths that is easily removed via the roll crimp. Ditto the same situation with a recently built .40-65 Ballard - the same exact situation as with the .32 dies wherein the die set's expander was a gross mismatch for my bullet diameter. (Pretty soft plain based bullets employed in both.)

Attached Files

  • Liked by
  • Glenn R. Latham
MP1886 posted this 02 February 2024

Tell you something else larry when the older RCBS dies were finished in raw metal they were very very tough and hard steel.  These ones today that are coated, well if you put the sizer die in the lathe and once you break through that coated they are fairly easy to machine with a carbide tool bit. Also you and talked one time about LEE sizer dies being on the larger side. Now that's mentioned many places on the internet. In fact do you have a LEE 7.62x25 sizer die? If so is it large? Mine is. 

Attached Files

Larry Gibson posted this 02 February 2024

Nice walk back......

Concealment is not cover.........

Attached Files

MP1886 posted this 02 February 2024

larry the expander I'm talking about here is as you said the Universal Neck Expander.  Over the decades RCBS, like other's have changed things. For example rememeber when their bullet seating die was solid with a small hole at the top for the bullet seating stem to pass through? It was also a smal diameter threaded stem, not the 1/4x28 most use today. They did this on some other dies too.  The one that peeves me the most is Hornady pistol dies, unless they changed it again, and that is the pistol expander die. The expander stem is pressed in, nothing you can do with it. So they thought. I just put it in my lathe and center drill a small hole through the top and then taks a punch and punch the expander out after I threaed the die in my press. Then you can do as you please with it except you can't make it larger unless you make one on the lathe. Nope don't like their arrangement at all. 

I'm glad you are having a good day, keep it up. 

Attached Files

Larry Gibson posted this 02 February 2024

 Max503

The expander plug MP 1886 has referred you to is the one, like mine, that fits on a 1/4x28 rod.  What you have is a pistol expander die in which the expander part is an integral part of the expander plug.  Again, I suggest a call to RCBS to see if the make a .358 one.  The Midway part MP 1886 suggest is the wrong part.

I'll check my own RCBS 38/357 dies and see if I can get a measurement on the thread size.

Thread size is .556 to .358 x 18 on 4 of my RCBS pistol expanders.

You might consider getting the RCBS universal expander die with the .358 plug MP 1886 suggested?

And, for MP 1886s edification I am having a great day......

LMG

Concealment is not cover.........

Attached Files

max503 posted this 02 February 2024

max503's questions [and the topic of the thread]  are;

"My questions are: Can I purchase a larger expander for this die?  My other question is, if I got on a lathe and made an expander, what size threaded rod/bolt would I make it out of?  The threads on the expander measure .558".  I couldn't match that up to an existing thread size."  

Whether or not one can purchase a larger expander for the RCBS die body can only be answered by RCBS.  

The rod size should be 1/4 x 28 as it is on my RCBS expander die.  That is the standard size rod used in many RCBS dies.  It is uses for the decap rod and seater stem.  A long replacement can be got and adapted to duplicate the one in your die.  However, the expander should screw off the rod(?) so the same rod can be used.  

That .588" measurement, is it the depth of the threaded hole or the diameter of the rod?

LMG

 

Well me to the rescue again. You don't have to call RCBS.  I can answer for you. Yes you can buy just the expander balls.  Look here:

https://www.midwayusa.com/product/1012109861?pid=783273

 

Have a good day Larry.

 

 ________________________________________________________________________________

Thank you for letting us know about this other good option.  Since I already own a Lee expander, and NOE makes plugs to fit it, I will just stay with what I've got.  But yes, according to your post RCBS sells a .358" expander that would fit my needs.  

Attached Files

Wilderness posted this 02 February 2024

I might be the odd one out here, but I actually prefer the design of my Lyman M Dies over the RCBS (which I also have).

I neither trim nor crimp my .30-30 cases. My chambers are way too long for even a maximally stretched .30-30 case, so I just let them grow until something kills them - and it won't be mouth splits. Ditto my .32-40 cases made from .30-30s and ending up short.

The M Die will be set to provide just enough second stage expansion for the shortest case. The depth of this larger diameter expanded portion will vary, but the portion that applies the grip to the bullet will be the same length on all cases.

By contrast, the RCBS (and Lee) dies if applied to cases of slightly differing length will apply everything from just enough flare up to a trumpet lookalike, and the length of grip will be variable.

With this setup I can avoid a general trimming of my cases just to bring them into line with a few shorter ones.

This preference of course applies just to those situations where variable case length is not a sin, or perhaps it is how we stop variable case length being a sin.

Sorry - a bit off topic.

Attached Files

  • Liked by
  • mashburn
  • Urny
MP1886 posted this 02 February 2024

max503's questions [and the topic of the thread]  are;

"My questions are: Can I purchase a larger expander for this die?  My other question is, if I got on a lathe and made an expander, what size threaded rod/bolt would I make it out of?  The threads on the expander measure .558".  I couldn't match that up to an existing thread size."  

Whether or not one can purchase a larger expander for the RCBS die body can only be answered by RCBS.  

The rod size should be 1/4 x 28 as it is on my RCBS expander die.  That is the standard size rod used in many RCBS dies.  It is uses for the decap rod and seater stem.  A long replacement can be got and adapted to duplicate the one in your die.  However, the expander should screw off the rod(?) so the same rod can be used.  

That .588" measurement, is it the depth of the threaded hole or the diameter of the rod?

LMG

 

Well me to the rescue again. You don't have to call RCBS.  I can answer for you. Yes you can buy just the expander balls.  Look here:

https://www.midwayusa.com/product/1012109861?pid=783273

 

Have a good day Larry.

 

 

Attached Files

MarkinEllensburg posted this 02 February 2024

.558 is the thread diameter of his expander. 9/16x18 thread. All RCBS pistol die sets that I own are this same size.

Attached Files

Larry Gibson posted this 02 February 2024

max503's questions [and the topic of the thread]  are;

"My questions are: Can I purchase a larger expander for this die?  My other question is, if I got on a lathe and made an expander, what size threaded rod/bolt would I make it out of?  The threads on the expander measure .558".  I couldn't match that up to an existing thread size."  

Whether or not one can purchase a larger expander for the RCBS die body can only be answered by RCBS.  

The rod size should be 1/4 x 28 as it is on my RCBS expander die.  That is the standard size rod used in many RCBS dies.  It is uses for the decap rod and seater stem.  A long replacement can be got and adapted to duplicate the one in your die.  However, the expander should screw off the rod(?) so the same rod can be used.  

That .588" measurement, is it the depth of the threaded hole or the diameter of the rod?

LMG

Concealment is not cover.........

Attached Files

  • Liked by
  • mashburn
Show More Posts
Categories
Search
Popular Tags
This Weeks High Earners
Hot Topics
Close