I am helping a friend who is new to reloading, work up a load for his new 1895 Marlin 45-70. He has lots of IMR 4227, so that will be the powder of choice. Bullet is a Lee 340 gr PB. He is after traditional trapdoor or 1886 power levels. We believe 25 to 30 grains will achieve this. Problem is this powder is pretty dense and leaves lots of free space in the case. We are now considering adding a filler. What kind of filler is best for this cartridge, and how it is it best applied?
Best Filler Material For 45-70
- 16K Views
- Last Post 09 July 2016
Air is the best filler, applied under the bullet and over the powder. HTH, Ric
Attached Files
nicely said Ric.I agree!
George
"if it was easy we'd let women do it" don't tell my wife I said that!
Attached Files
Something is always the “BEST” for one reason or another. I use a lot of different fillers. The easiest one for just filling light load airspace for powder ignition in large bore straight walled .45 cal. cartridges is right at your Value Hardware Store.
Gary
Attached Files
I dont think many that shoot CBA Military Big Bore matches use filler.I know Ric has won quite a few matches not using it.I dont like fillers and if a load needs it to shoot well i would look for a different powder.I played with Super Grex in a 30 BR and 30-30 a 20 or so years ago and got it to work OK but never any better than a non filler load.Some that used it back then got a build up in the throat of the during the course a of a match.It was not too easy to remove so they stopped using it.
Gary-your “backer rod” is the same material that plainbase shooter use to hold the powder back on their cases for breech seat loads.It is “sill sealer” they use and thinner but works well.I tried it on 30-06 plainbase loads but holding the powder back didn't give me any better accuracy with my 7-8g of Bullseye loads. .
"if it was easy we'd let women do it" don't tell my wife I said that!
Attached Files
Poly fill, the stuff you find in old pillows wll work.
Attached Files
Poly fill, the stuff you find in old pillows wll work.
true.the one case where i i saw huge improvement was my buddies 7.62 Russian and 16g 2400.With no filler 2"+ groups,with filler about 1.5".But when he bumped it to 17g and no filler it shot just as well.
"if it was easy we'd let women do it" don't tell my wife I said that!
Attached Files
I have the dacron poly and the BP filler which I have used in other cartridges. I also have some corn meal, which some old timers like, but I would prefer to use something a little cleaner. I was just wondering what the more experienced shooters prefered in the 45-70, and what worked well for them. I did not want to try to reinvent the wheel here if possible. My friend does have a lesser amount of Unique powder on hand, which currently is almost impossible to replace due to market conditions. That's why at this point we hesitated to use it. Lyman no longer gives cast load data in the 45-70 using Unique, for some reason. I have heard around 14 to 15 grains works fine. Maybe that will fill the case more, eliminating the need for a filler. I do like the idea of using the poly foam, but doesn't that melt upon firing and gum up the bore?
Attached Files
The 1/2” diameter Frost King Poly Foam just blows out of the muzzle like any other filler. It does not leave burned/melted poly in the barrel but you will find spent slightly scorched plugs of it a few yards downrange.
The BPI original is my first choice but it is nearly the same per pound as powder. The best feature of BPI Original is that it acts as a Quasi gas check and extends the load range of plain based bullets significantly.
PRPSB is also a filler I use and much less costly than BPI, but it is heavier being a spherical particulate instead of the fluffy BPI original. PRPSB also has a significant cleaning effect on your bores. PRPSB:
Corn meal and other coarse vegetable fiber fillers are even heavier and more potentially dangerous due to their weight. All vegetable/bio-fillers readily absorb moisture from the air and I stay away from them.
Gary
Attached Files
Incidently, I hope you and your friend do better with the Lee 457-340-RNF than I did. That mold dropped bullets .457” in diameter with #2 alloy and my .458 Win Mag likes cast bullets .460-.461” or it shoots all over the place. I had to hone the Lee 340 mold out to drop bullets .460” before they would group 1"at 50 yards for me at any load level. Before honing the mold out, my groups were 3-6” at 50 yards and mostly off target paper at 100 yards.
Gary
Attached Files
Gentlemen , do NOT use fillers,they might cause chamber rings ,or worse .
If you have to use a filler,you are using the wrong powder or primer. or both.
I use large rifle magnum or Winchester large rilfle primers in the 375H&H ,458 Lott and 416 Rigby with loads of shotgun powders and have no problems.
Now I am using AQUILA L CHEDDITE, a powder studied for 36 grams of shot in the 12 gauge.( a little more than 1 ounce and 1/8)
A little slower than Unique.
Fillers add a variable ,cost time and money and most nobody that is anybody uses them anymore..
And if you take them filler loads afield ,either they are packed tight as in the shotgun shells or they move in the case.
In the case of 45/70 Marlin with Lee's light bullets ,stay away from fillers and undersized bollets get a four cavity 460 bullet .From LBT or Accurate Molds et coetera. I load Accurate but gentle loads killing the boars ,if I connect.
Vihtavuori 120 burns badly in the 45/70 while Vihtavuori N 110 burns well ,at the 24 grains level.
N120 is similar ti 4227 , while N110 is similar to 2400.
I like to say that fillers in smokeless loads, are like double acton in automatic pistols ,a complicated solution to a nonexistent problem..
Of course Black powder cartriges are another world,light loads of black powder must be compressed in the cartridge..
Attached Files
PS Read with attention the late two or three Lyman manuals ,and the old cast bullet manuals.
In the49th edition read at page 445,They still put unique in the 45/70 ,look at the loads in the Contender pistol 45/70.
The Lyman manual perpetuates a lot of obsolete old wives tales on cast bullets ,as the size to diameters of cast bullet.
Like many other reloading manuals , they are essentially advertising catalogs for their reloading tools.
Powder makers and bullet makers are more useful for us.
Attached Files
There are a few specific reasons that fillers can cause chamber rings. A generalization such as yours is unfair and nonfactual.
There may be more reasons but these are the reasons I know of that can cause chamber ringing with fillers:
1) loose filler not completely filling the airspace, causes a pressure spike similar to a bore obstruction.
2) loose hard fillers that act like a plug with combustion blowing by and around, again causing a pressure spike.
3) heavy filler weight not added to bullet weight for a total projectile weight. This may put you past safe pressure level for your firearm.
4) using a filler with very fast pistol powders that are sensitive to case volume. Again causing a pressure spike.
If these things aren't common sense to you, Brain-up and learn something before fooling with fillers. Don't just blindly be in terror of fillers. An excellent informational primer on the safe use of fillers is at:
This is not a short read and could save the life of an ignorant person from improper use of fillers.
Most shooters want to try fillers due to a low volume charge of a relatively slow powder for a reduced load level, using fast pistol powder in that application is a reasonable blunder to avoid that some shooters will never heed and they will continue to curse fillers because of the damage and injury they cause. Using the slow powder with a reduced charge leaves an airspace that the filler remedies in wide applications.
Sure, selection of a recommended powder giving the same low load level desired is the best idea, and for rifle, H4895 has manufacturers recommendations for reduced loads down to 60% of case volume for cartridges that H4895 is recommended. Cases over 60% full of H4895 dont have ignition problems due to airspace or position sensitivity.
Gary
Attached Files
Please do not take offense, i do not mean to be rude or offensive.
Everibody is free to use fillers and double action autopistols and steckers or schnellers on their hunting rifles.
As I do have the right of not using them.
I am a cast bullet shooter since 1969 and I have read something since then.
Let me shake hands with RICINYAKIMA and LINOWW and the shooters that do not use fillers.
Attached Files
I am helping a friend who is new to reloading, work up a load for his new 1895 Marlin 45-70. He has lots of IMR 4227, so that will be the powder of choice. Bullet is a Lee 340 gr PB. He is after traditional trapdoor or 1886 power levels. We believe 25 to 30 grains will achieve this. Problem is this powder is pretty dense and leaves lots of free space in the case. We are now considering adding a filler. What kind of filler is best for this cartridge, and how it is it best applied?ÂÂ
In the .405 Win I use a 3/4” square of paper towel pushed in so as not to touch but be just above the powder. It burns completely and with the powders I've tried it leaves a very clean bore. It has made position sensitive powders consistent in ignition.
Attached Files
onondaga, My friend lucked out on the new Lee mold. The bullets drop out at .459- .460 when cast of WW.
Attached Files
I'll stand with Giorgio, Rick, And Linow. Find a better powder, primer combination. Brodie
B.E.Brickey
Attached Files
I'll stand with Giorgio, Rick, And Linow. Find a better powder, primer combination.
Brodie
I stand in that row, too. The only filler I've ever used with a 45/70 is 4831. I “rang” a chamber on a very valuable rifle barrel with one. It wasn't in a 45/70 but, a 30 cal. Once bitten shy forever!!!!
Frank
Attached Files
Please do not take offense, i do not mean to be rude or offensive.
Everibody is free to use fillers and double action autopistols and steckers or schnellers on their hunting rifles.
As I do have the right of not using them.
I am a cast bullet shooter since 1969 and I have read something since then.
Let me shake hands with RICINYAKIMA and LINOWW and the shooters that do not use fillers.
ÂÂ
Hi giorgio (Italian for 'great guy'), I shake yer hand also...Dan
Attached Files
I like to say that fillers in smokeless loads, are like double acton in automatic pistols ,a complicated solution to a nonexistent problem.. a quote from the famous Italian hog hunter.
I could not agree with you more. I have used the DA remark ever since the introduction of the wonder 9 in the 80's. All hype and BS. What did these guys do that Walther did not do in 1935 with the P-38?
My trapdoor likes 27 gr of IMR4227 with a 380gr bullet. NO FILLER.
Ric says no fillers, I use no fillers. He threatens me if I don't listen and I shoot with him at least once a week. The stress is unbearable!
RicinYakima --> :drillsgt:
Attached Files
Make room for one more giorgio. Have been reloading since the early 60's and have never used any type of filler in order to make accurate loads and never will.
RD
Attached Files
Categories
- All Categories
- General Polls
- Contact Us w/ Forum Issues
- Welcome to The Cast Bullet Association Forum
- General
- Bullet Casting
-
Guns and Shooting
- AR Platform
- TC Contenders & Other Single Shot Handguns
- Shotguns
- Informal Matches & Other Shooting Events
- Gunsmithing Tips
- Gun Cleaning & Maintenance
- Optics
- Benchrest Cast Bullet Shooting
- Military Bench Rest Cast Bullet Shooting
- Silhouette Shooting
- Postal Match Cast Bullet Shooting
- Factory Guns
- Black Powder Cartridge
- Hand Guns
- Lever Guns
- Single Shot Rifles
- Bolt Action Rifles
- Military Surplus Rifles
- Plinkers Hollow
- Muzzleloaders
- Hunting
- Reloading
- Buy, Sell or Trade
- Other Information & Reference
Search
This Weeks High Earners
- Aaron 20
- jeff houck 20
- Tom Acheson 15
- Wilderness 14
- John Carlson 13
- sghart3578 10
- MarkinEllensburg 10
- Spindrift 5
- alphabrass 5
- SkinnerD 5